The review process is an essential aspect of the publication process of an article. It enables authors to improve their manuscripts and aids editors in making decisions on manuscripts. Islamika Inside employs a double-blind peer review system.

A double-blind peer review system is an anonymous review system whereby the identity of the author(s) of a manuscript is concealed from the selected reviewers. All details that may enable a reviewer to identify a manuscript's author(s) are removed from the manuscript before the manuscript is sent to the reviewer. Similarly, the reviewers’ identities are also concealed from the author(s) when sending the reviewers’ comments to the author(s).

Islamika Inside considers the double-blind peer system a more effective review system because it limits possible bias from selected reviewers or authors.